Tinsel is making a big comeback this Christmas, but it never really left.

Literally.

Ghosts of Christmas Past seem to appear in the most unlikely places.

While recently sorting through some dusty old Buster Brown shoe boxes filled with fading pink Spalding balls, metal skate keys, plastic Ratfinks, and tiny Disneykin figurines, glittering strands of decades-old silver tinsel were tangled among the toys.

1950’s Tinsel Icicles

Old Christmas memories never die and neither does mid-century tinsel. This stuff stuck to childhood Angora sweaters, corduroy, and made its way back home with me on the bottom of rubber-soled saddle shoes as we trimmed the Christmas tree in our elementary school classroom. The crinkly, tinsel icicles were placed with great care and pride and could take hours.

That stringy shiny silvery stuff usually gotten at Woolworths had a way of hanging around long after the holiday, hiding in shag carpets for decades.

It’s no surprise that the tinsel of our youth had a long shelf life.

Like the celadon green painted walls of our elementary school classroom, the tinsel we decorated our Christmas trees with was made of lead.

Ho! Ho! Ho!

For way over half a century, lead foil was the perfect material for this ubiquitous silvery Christmas decoration. Non-flammable, it was not only safe, it was pretty, festive, and cheap.

Tony Tinsel

But its origins are a lot tonier than the Five and Dime store flimsy tinsel we think of.

Once upon a time, tinsel was so expensive only the wealthiest families had access to it.

It just didn’t just glitter silver- it was actually made of the metal.

In 17th century Germany, the first Christmas trees were embellished with tinsel made from real silver pressed into strips. Long before electric lights, trees were decorated with real lit candles and the sparkling silver combined with the flickering light created a twinkly effect that worked as a percussor to modern-day string lights.

Copper and Tin

By the early 1900s Christmas traditions imported by German immigrants became mainstream in America and middle-class folks were looking for affordable ways to beautify their evergreens in their living rooms. Silver tinsel was too dear for most people’s pocketbooks. Manufacturers began making tinsel out of copper, tin, and aluminum. They produced the same sparkle as silver but for a fraction of the price and became very popular.

They could be used year after year and lovingly packed away with ornaments. Unfortunately, the aluminum paper in tinsel was very flammable.

WWI Tinsel Goes to War

When WWI broke out in 1914, tin was in short supply, and copper production was reserved for war efforts.

Tinsel quickly disappeared from holiday displays.

Lead takes the Lead

Manufacturers were still trying to figure out the perfect tinsel. This was a beloved holiday decoration. They needed to come up with the right material to use. The obvious choice was lead. Valued in paints and children’s toys, what better metal for Christmas cheer.

By the 1920s lead-foil tinsel exploded in popularity and became mass-produced. Lead-based tinsel was a hit and the gold standard for tinsel production for decades.

A German Co became the face of tinsel with Stanniol Lamella which translates into tiny blade

Lead revived tinsel from obscurity and soon it was embraced as a standard Christmas component along with ornaments and electric lights.

A 1959 newspaper article on holiday safety pointed out: “Tinsel is fairly safe because even if kiddies decide to swallow it will not cause poisoning.”

By the 1960s scientists began to question the safety of lead.

Tinsel was not fairly safe.

Awareness of the risks of lead poisoning would spell the end for lead-based tinsel. Ingested or absorbed through the skin it causes headaches, vomiting, and even brain and kidney damage.

The FDA got involved. They reached an agreement with tinsel importers and manufacturers, putting an end to lead tinsel in the U.S. in 1972. The 1972 change was at first kept secret, Popular Science reports, for fear “that many people preferring the lead variety would stockpile it,” an official said at the time.

Today’s trendy tinsel is made of safer polyvinyl chloride, shredded shiny ribbons of plastic.

PVC tinsel won’t poison the family.

It will just ultimately poison the earth.

Merry Christmas!