I did the caring. Who cares for me?
Social media has been on fire since Saturday Night Live aired “Sister,” a mock commercial in which John Mulaney presents an ingenious solution to caring for an aging parent without disrupting his own life: his sister.
The sketch is funny because it is a little too true.
I immediately pictured my brother seated in the lone chair in a parent’s hospital room, buried behind his Newsday. Meanwhile, I was racing through the halls looking for a nurse, checking medications and charts, calling doctors and social workers, trying to figure out what happened next.
He was there. But somehow, everything that needed doing was mine to do.
That distinction feels familiar. For years, I confused my brother’s presence with something I kept hoping would accompany it: compassion, reciprocity, an interest in someone’s needs besides his own.
My brother Andy has been on my mind lately. The disappointments in our relationship. The distance. And my stubborn willingness to keep reaching across it, as though this time there might be someone reaching back.
Keeping Kryptonite
Anyone who knows me knows I am a saver. I hold on to things for both sentimental and historical value. And that is the deep pull with my brother Andy. Despite his emotional distance and repeated disappointments, I keep returning, only to be hurt again. Then it dawned on me: holding on to him is like Superman keeping kryptonite for sentimental reasons because it came from his original planet.
Of course he would want a piece of home. Imagine the longing attached to that fragment: proof of where he came from, something solid from a vanished world. I understand that longing.
But there’s a big catch. This piece of home also drains him of his strength. His power.
Survivor
As an artist, I find stories in what survives. Old periodicals, childhood school books, vintage scraps of paper someone else would have thrown away. I understand the pull of a fragment from a vanished world. Something seemingly insignificant can contain an entire childhood.
My brother is part of mine. With our parents gone, we are the surviving members of the original Four. The world before it disappeared. He remembers the rooms in our mid-century suburban house, the smell of Fritos wafting from our dog Prince’s paws, and the muffled voices of my parents arguing late at night as we stood cowering in the hallway listening. There are things I don’t have to explain to him because he was there. But Andy was always the weakest link in the Fab 4.
I keep mistaking that shared history for the possibility of closeness now.
My primal mistake, perhaps, was believing in the supreme importance of my primary family. Like the mafia, I thought it was sealed in blood. As though being born into the same household guaranteed a lifetime of care, and the last remaining member must be held on to at any cost.
And I have kept paying. Dearly.
I just wanted ordinary reciprocity and compassion. Basic kindness.
Feeding Him. Starving For Kindness
For over twenty years, when I lived in my house, my brother came to visit with my parents every Sunday, like clockwork. He was emotionally distant even then, but he showed up. I cooked and fed him more than 1,000 Sunday dinners. I kept setting the table, believing we were keeping something together.
When I had my penthouse in New York, there was a large lush terrace to enjoy for family events. Later, there was a pool, a big house, a place for all the family holidays and celebrations. I provided the setting, the food, the welcome. And the love
After both my parents died, my brother left me high and dry. I no longer served a purpose. And after I lost my house, I now came without amenities.
No terrace, no pool, no sprawling house in which to host everyone. I had only myself to offer.
After all those years of feeding him, I am starving for kindness from him.
Lost in a Storm
During Hurricane Sandy, my husband and I lost electricity and heat for more than six weeks, like so many others on Long Island. My brother lived five minutes away from us, in a large five-bedroom house, and was miraculously unaffected by the storm.
He never invited us for a meal or offered us a place to stay in his warm home. He let us charge our phones, then asked us to leave after a few hours.
Back into the dark. Back to our cold house.
Yet I still look to him for warmth.
That is difficult to admit.
So is the lingering hope of a little sister that persists even after so much evidence. Perhaps the next phone call or email will be different. Perhaps this time he will show an interest, ask a question, offer something without my having to ask.
Recently, when my HuffPost essays came out, I received an avalanche of positive responses to the story I had kept secret for over 50 years- my college gang rape. His lackluster two-word response was just one pebble in that avalanche. An annoying pebble I couldn’t stop feeling. Somehow, I gave it more weight than all the warmth that had come my way.
I wanted my brother to recognize the writer I had become. Instead, I let his judgment outweigh my own.
I mistakenly allowed his distance to become evidence of something lacking in me.
My brother is a journalist. A real writer. With real degrees. I am the artist with no fancy degrees who doesn’t even know what a dangling participle is
Even with a book published by Doubleday and years of essays behind me, I hesitate and choke to ever say, “I’m a writer.” I may as well say I’m a brain surgeon. I can almost hear him mocking me as an imposter. I fear his dismissal so much that I do the work for him, diminishing myself before he even gets the chance.

The colonial wooden stocks were a childhood photo opportunity. My fear of my brother’s judgment held me much longer. He was the journalist. I was the artist. I should stay in my lane. Even with a published book and years of essays behind me, I struggled to call myself a writer. I am learning I don’t need his permission to be one.
There is shame in admitting how much power I have given him.
At my age, with a lifetime of work behind me, I am still waiting for my older brother’s approval like the little sister I am. Readers tell me my words have reached them, and yet I am still listening for the one voice that might tell me I have no business writing them.
My mistake is allowing that voice to become my own.
What I want to release from my body is the waiting, the shrinking before I have even spoken. The effort of trying once again to make a connection that leaves me feeling smaller. Eternally disappointed.
Perhaps this is where my mistake becomes my mission and is useful to someone else. Through my writing, I can speak honestly about the loyalties we carry long after they begin to hurt us.
This was my mistake. I had confused something’s connection to my past with its right to remain close to me. I could not recognize what preserving hope was costing me.
I will always care about where I came from.
But I don’t have to keep kryptonite close to my heart to remember home.
© Sally Edelstein and Envisioning The American Dream, 2026. Unauthorized use and/or duplication of this material without express and written permission from this blog’s author and/or owner is strictly prohibited. Excerpts and links may be used, provided that full and clear credit is given to Sally Edelstein and Envisioning The American Dream with appropriate and specific direction to the original content.














I hope this essay is saying you have freed yourself of wanting something from your brother that will evidently not be forthcoming. Your plight is not uncommon though it is always heart wrenching and sad. I have seen it in my family and experienced it in a marriage. It’s very tough to make the break, but I believe it is the right choice. We don’t get to choose our families!
LikeLike