WWI Remembering the Others That Served

WWI soldiers

As America entered the Great War in 1917, Uncle Sam encouraged all his “hyphenated” American nieces and nephews to join him in fighting this war to end all wars.

While we celebrate the centennial of Armistice Day, the shadow of anti-Semitism still casts a dark cloud over us. It is worth remembering that approximately 225,000 Jewish-Americans served proudly in WWI.

Among them was my Jewish maternal grandfather Arthur Joseph.

It was with great pride that a few years after the signing of the Armistice that Arthur and his wife my grandmother Sadie  listened as his former Commander, General John Pershing Commander of the American Expeditiary Force  deliver a stirring speech  extolling the value of the Jewish serviceman. The speech was given in 1926 in the majestic halls of the great Gothic Cathedral of St. John the Divine in upper Manhattan at an interfaith meeting to aid the suffering of Jews in Eastern Europe.

“ When the time came to serve their country under arms,” General Pershing said, “no class of people served with more patriotism or with higher motives than the young Jews who volunteered or were drafted and who went overseas with our other young Americans.

WWI soldier

To Make the World Safe for Democracy my grandfather served with dignity as an American and as a Jew. A second generation American, he was born in N.Y.C. to Hungarian immigrants who had lived in the country for over 25 years. But he was always a Jewish-American.

There was still resistance to the “hyphenated” Americans despite the fact that nearly a quarter of the men sent to fight in Europe in 1918 were foreign-born.  Many had only arrived from Ellis Island months or years earlier when they enlisted.

By the time of the war the melting pot was roiling.

With one in three Americans in 1918 either born abroad or of foreign-born parents, resentment of immigrants became part of the Great American melting pot recipe. The idea of hyphenated Americans citizens who identified as Italian-Americans or Jewish-Americans made many native born citizens uneasy.

Terms like yid, kike, mick, dago, and polack, were tossed around as casually as baseballs. .

Former President Theodore Roosevelt encouraged the suspicion of hyphenated Americans insisting that all citizens no matter their birthright or ethnic heritage should embrace “the simple and loyal motto America for Americans.”

Sound familiar?

Immigrants along with Jews would prove critical to the country’s effort in WWI.  Despite their importance, America closed its borders in the years after the Armistice, ending what had been the largest immigration flow in the country’s history.

With American Jewish participation in WWI, Rabbi Stephen Wise wrote optimistically in a 1917 N.Y. Times op ed:  that military service would “ mark the burial, without the hope of resurrection, of hyphenism and will token the birth of a united and indivisible country.”

A dream that is clearly unrealized.

It’s time to call an armistice to hate of the Other.


 © Sally Edelstein and Envisioning The American Dream, 2018. Unauthorized use and/or duplication of this material without express and written permission from this blog’s author and/or owner is strictly prohibited. Excerpts and links may be used, provided that full and clear credit is given to Sally Edelstein and Envisioning The American Dream with appropriate and specific direction to the original content.



One comment

  1. Oh no, you forgot “Frog” for the French. As a French immigrant to Canada, I heard that constantly. Be that as it may, I personally think that indeed, the hyphenation should be dropped and by the immigrants, deliberately and voluntarily. When you come to a country, you adapt to that country, unless it means adapting to blatant evil ways. I am definitely NOT a “French-Canadian” even though I have a dual citizenship. I am strictly a Canadian. I came here to experience a new life, not to drag in old ways I was leaving behind because they no longer served. I believe, like Gandhi, that I am all, and nothing. I have long advocated that immigrants drop their old traditions and fully integrate into their new world, including their religions. Not a popular stance, but the wisest one in the end. Stand out, insist on special rights or treatment and set yourself up for persecution – that’s the reality. Humans don’t change, no matter how much veneer of “political correctness” is painted on them.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: