Will Operation June Cleaver Be Deployed in 2020

 

Get ready to set your clocks back, kids.

No, it’s not daylight savings time yet, but it’s about to get darker a lot earlier than many of us hoped for.

A woman whose religious beliefs require her to absolute obedience to a husband lest she is “shamed, shunned or humiliated” is poised to occupy the same seat as Ruth Bader Ginsburg that tireless champion of gender equality.

Trump’s nomination of right-wing conservative Amy Barrett threatens a systemic unraveling of decades hard-won and hard-fought-for fights that have given American women some semblance of autonomy and control in their lives.

This transition feels impossible but it’s not.

Women have had their autonomy and freedom pulled out from them before. After WWII a massive campaign went into effect to get the independent working women of America back to the home, hearth, and hubby and the mid-century mythologizing of the happy housewife and her family went into full tilt.  Women transitioned from working woman to a homemaker with seemingly push-button ease.

75 years ago images of working women suddenly disappeared from the media and it took them over 30 years to return.

During WWII women might have thought that they were finally free, out in the world …until they weren’t.

Vintage ads WWII Wacs and 1950s housewife

Women went from serving the country to serving hubby a beer. L) Vintage ad Canada Drive 1944 (R) Vintage Schlitz Ad 1953

One day, dedicated working women were glorified, proudly featured in articles and advertisements; the next they vanished, replaced by dewy-eyed brides, and happy homemakers with nothing more taxing on their minds than getting rid of ring around the collar.

In a blink of an eye, women went from serving the country to serving hubby a beer.

But this wasn’t a campaign to raise awareness. It was a tactical decision.

Most of these women didn’t opt out of working; it was more like they were pushed out by Uncle Sam: “Here’s your pillbox hat. What’s your hurry!”

As fierce as Uncle Sam’s Rosie the Riveter campaign was  (deployed in WWII to recruit women into the depleted workforce) once victory was in view a decidedly different, equally aggressive, operation was launched aimed at these same women.

WWII Women Postwar kitchen GE

Women transitioned from working woman to a homemaker with push buttons ease. (L) Woman war worker -Vintage ad General Electric 1943 (R) Housewife vintage ad

Not unlike the post war US defense policy, the media went on a permanent war footing against positive portrayals of women in the workplace.

It was now all-out war to get the ladies back into their soon to be fully-loaded Kelvinator kitchens and into high heels.

It would be more than a decade until this secret campaign would reveal itself: “Operation: June Cleaver” would be a huge success!

My mother Betty along with millions of other women of the greatest generation would be one of it’s casualties.

All Out War

Vintage WWII Recruitment Poster for Women

Vintage WWII Recruitment Poster

It was wartime.

The patriotism was so thick you could cut it with a knife. Everywhere you looked, posters, ads, and articles appeared applauding the resourcefulness and ingenuity of Americas working woman, that patriotic lass who had stepped up to fill the shoes of the boys who had gone off to war.

 

Vintage illustration WWII women work greyhound ad

Rosie the Riveter rides the greyhound bus to her job

No effort was spared to get these ladies out of their homes and into the defense plants.

The campaign orchestrated by  Uncle Sam’s Office of War Information in collaboration with Madison Avenue,  women’s magazines, radio producers, and Hollywood, tried overnight to make wearing overalls and operating a lathe glamorous.

When Uncle Sam came calling, these ladies “leaned in” and took over the manpower.

Working girls were the new glamor girls and for impressionable teens like my mother Betty, it was empowering.

 

WWII Women McCalls

What a difference a year makes. McCalls Magazine went from table setting tips pictured on the left 1941, to a war worker plotting her blueprint for a bomber on the right, 1942. Women were no longer pictured as weak, non mechanical incapable of leadership or unsuited for the challenges of the world.“The day of the lady loafer is almost over.” boasted Margaret Hickey chairperson of the Women’s Advisory Committee to the War Manpower Commission

With the bombing of Pearl Harbor, our very notion of a woman’s place was decimated.

A public more accustomed to seeing their women depicted in dainty dresses while luxing the family dishes were now being bombarded with images of hardy gals dressed in coveralls and bright bandanas doing a mans job

There was nothing a woman couldn’t do and the media couldn’t stop gushing about her.

You’re No Sissy Now!

WWII Vintage illustration American Women war workers

Typical of these positive ads was one from Kotex.  Geared to high school girls like my mother, it typified the wartime emphasis on female strength: “Remember when the boys used to say that girls were made of sugar and spice and all things nice? Those days are gone forever…you’re no sissy now!…”

Talk about girl power!

For a 16-year-old girl, it was all thrilling. All around Betty were wives mothers and older women actively engaged in non-traditional work; women who had a feeling of accomplishment proud to be part of the war effort. These jobs gave them confidence and a new sense of their capabilities.

Betty Co-ed

vintage illustration newspaperwoman and Brenda Starr

(L) Vintage Illustration 1948 by Harry Fredman “Women’s Home Companion” (R) Vintage Brenda Starr Comic Book 1940s

By the fall of 1945, Betty was a college freshman at the University of Connecticut who took her studies seriously.

As editor of Brooklyn’s Erasmus High School newspaper, she had dreams of being a star reporter for a big city daily. But no sob sister stories for her- she didn’t want to get stuck covering the usual girl beat of weddings and social clubs.

No sir, she fancied herself more as a glamorous foreign correspondent type like Martha Gellhorn one of the greatest war correspondents of the twentieth century and the only woman to land at Normandy on D-Day. Married to Ernest Hemingway they traveled the front lines together.

Perhaps, Betty pondered, one day she might even report from the front lines standing by her beau Stanley a Marine serving overseas.

A Fellah Needs a Girl

Vintage illustration Rosie the Riveter WWII

“Hats off to the Woman of the Year” begins this 1942 ad from Mutual Life Insurance, lavishing praise on Americas working woman.

 

Our fighting boys were proud of these women.

Throughout the war, the armed forces newspaper, The Stars and Stripes had been bursting with pride with uplifting, home-front stories of the swell of patriotic cuties in blue overalls and hair bandanas, standing shoulder to shoulder with their men, taking up the load for Uncle Sam.

But as the war drew to a close, Uncle Sam started whistling a different tune, as in a widely circulated War Dept. brochure proclaiming that: “A woman is merely a substitute, like using plastic instead of metal.”

Fueled by fears there wouldn’t be enough jobs for returning servicemen and that Depression conditions might return, the campaign to get women out of the workforce began in earnest. That, coupled with pent-up desires of both women and men to start a family were unleashed, producing an unprecedented idealization of the nuclear family.

The ideal of the family served as a national unifier becoming a symbol of what the American system was all about. It’s what they were fighting for.

vintage illustration 1940s mother and child

Motherhood and the proliferation of baby images were churned out from 1944-1946. Women were about to be enshrined as wives and mothers .

With the same secrecy of the Potsdam conference, a final meeting between Uncle Sam and his media allies commenced to clarify “the post-war administration of women” and the rebuilding of the American family.

Those same glowing home front stories now took a more scolding tone accusing these same patriotic girls of doing “unwomanly” jobs and taking jobs away from the returning men.

The Way We Were

collage vintage ads Texaco WWII Work Changes

GI Joe gets his job back ((L) Vintage Texaco ad praising the working woman 1943 . R) Texaco ad 1945 “I’ll be a Texaco service man again when I get home.”

Articles and advertisements began to appear, that seemed to speak directly to the battle fatigued boys overseas. One ad for instance featured a soldier in combat wistfully daydreaming about the peaceful world he has left behind, yearning for the familiarity of home: “I want my girl back just as she is.”

The media assured the boys  the American Dream would be there when they returned, that “life would be just as you left it.”

Including your job…and your best girl.

Blue Print For The American Dream

Vintage Kelvinator ad 1945 family

“… Yes these were the things I was fighting for, waiting for…the soldier asserts.” Vintage ad Kelvinator 1945

No series of advertisements served up a bigger helping of the post-war  American Dream than the brashly sentimental ads of Nash-Kelvinator.

The ads took on the tone of a letter often written by the hometown gal he left behind who had plenty to dream about too.

In this ad from 1945 the soldier pleads that once he comes home:

“…don’t let anyone tamper with a way of living that works so well.”

“Never fear darling,” – his sweetheart writes him back, that’s the way we all want it. Everything will be here, just as you left it, just as you want it…when you come back to me!

And when you come back from the war you will find, just as you left them, everything your letters tell me you hold dear.

….inside in the living room you’ll find your easy chair, your footstool and your slippers, just as they always were each night before you went away to war.

When you come back you will find nothing changed. Those at home promised that. Here in your town your children are still free to sleep and laugh and play…still free to look at the sky, clear-eyed and unafraid…our house still stands lovely as it always was…

“…Yes, back home to the same town to the same job , you liked so much…to the same America we have always known and loved…where you can work and plan and build…where together we can do things we’ve always dreamed of…where we and our children are free to make our lives what we want them to be…where there is no limits…

…where nothing has changed.

And We’ll Live Happily Every After

Postwar promises Kelvinator 750 Scan00232 - Copy

”You’ve said, That’s the America I want when I come home again. Ads promised GI Joe that His wife and son will make life what it ought to be once more.

“That’s the America I fought for…that’s the America I’ll be looking for when I come home.”

The way things were.

But the fairy tale American Dream didn’t include a working woman.

I Want My Girl Back Just As She Is

Vintage illustration s WWII Women Work and housework Overseas, Betty’s beau Stanley worried.

With Victory in Europe nearing, Seargent First Class Stanley began to echo his GI buddies concerns: “Exactly what was getting into these dames anyway?”

Looking longingly at the pin-up of Betty Grable on his Barracks locker, he began to question what the heck they were fightin’ for if all the girls back home had their heads filled with a lot of hot air and plain baloney.

Would the women be willing to return to the home after the war, they worried in unison.

WWII Women jobs newspapers housewife

Even Hemingway was resentful of his glamorous wife Martha Gellhorn’s long absences during her reporting assignments. He famously wrote her “Are you a war correspondent or a wife in my bed? Needless to say They divorced in 1945

Stanley thought about Betty away from home, at college susceptible to all kinds of ideas and nonsense.

He knew she had her heart set on being an ace reporter, solving mysteries, and having fabulous adventures. But he didn’t really want her globetrotting around the world in search of sensational stories, not to mention the steamy romances.

And even if Betty did stay at home in N.Y. and get that job as a reporter for a daily paper, he still worried.

Newsrooms were he-man territory. They were smoked filled, grubby joints with spittoons on the floor and racy pin-ups on the wall.

He imagined her going out after work with the boys, downing whiskey at some smoky watering hole, staying out late betting on some palooka. This Sergeant First Class didn’t want his wife shouting at boxing matches when she should be home darning his socks and cooking a casserole for him. …and taking care of the children.

Back Home For Keeps

vintage illustration housewife and industry factories

The big push back

 

Stanley was right. Back at school, Betty’s head was being filled with all kinds of ideas and nonsense. But not what he feared.

Operation June Cleaver had begun on the homefront.

Suddenly it seemed, wherever you turned a fierce campaign was being launched with ominous warnings aimed at the modern women.

WWII Women work postwar driving

It was now important to keep your man in the driver’s seat. It was soon feared that the masculinization of career women would drive him away.

The women’s magazines once filled with glowing stories of courageous women  were now filled with threatening articles implying that careers and higher education were leading to the masculinization of women with dangerous consequences to the country, the home, the children.

If a woman held an important professional position, they implied, she would lose her womanly qualities affecting the ability of the women as well as her husband to obtain sexual gratification!

And if a career woman had children, watch out.

She turned them into “juvenile delinquents,” “criminals” and “confirmed alcoholics.”

Or worse…she could end up an old maid.

The Tide had Turned

collage vintage WWII Women Wacs and 1950s Housewife

(L) Vintage Magazine cover Colliers 1944 (R) Vintage Tide ad

 

With victory the tide had turned against working women.

Gone were the ads telling women they could do anything a man could do. Gone were the ads congratulating women for performing double duty on the homefront so brilliantly.

Instead, ads began appeared affirming the new conventional wisdom – there was no more important job than wife and mother.

WWII Women 7up career family

7-UP ads ceased claiming it would produce a good disposition in women in order to win a better job as the ad on the left proclaims, to boasting the beverage would help them be happy homemakers and bring good family cheer.

 

Up In smoke

WWII Women war and brides

Women’s aspirations would soon go up in smoke. During the war, Chesterfield had frequent ad supporting military recruitment and factory work. By 1946 they featured a bride.

 

Nuclear Family

Vintage illustration American family 1940s

The ideal of the family served as a national unifier becoming a symbol of what the American system was all about.

It’s what they were fighting for.

After Rosie the Riveter finished her stint on the assembly line, Uncle Sam wanted her to keep up the same wartime production…only this time, in bed.

The family was about to go nuclear.

vintage illustration babies

Here Come the baby boomers Vintage ad Swan Soap 1945

 

Ashamed at even thinking of being a career girl, Betty worried not only about losing her femininity but whether Stanley would leave her when he returned?

Betty felt so dull and droopy.  Now all she could dream about was marriage and a warm and cozy home together, just like she and Stanley talked about.

With Victory here, all thoughts turned to the future.

Post War Promises: Occupation:Wife

Vintage ad Wife Insurance 1946

There was no more important job than being a wife and mother. So important in fact that in 1946 The Penn Mutual Life Insurance Company offered “wife insurance” in case the poor widowed hubby was left having to cook, clean, shop, do laundry, …etc for himself!

Like many war born romances, Betty’s relationship with Stanley soon fizzled out.

But in the fall of 1945 with a post-war bounce in her step, Betty returned to school more determined than ever to excel, clear in the things that were really important.

She came to the realization that the highest value and only real worthwhile commitment for a woman was the fulfillment of themselves as wives and mothers.

A barrage of books and an onslaught of articles bombarded the media convincing women to stay home. Working women became the target of vehement attacks by academia, industry, and politicians. In fact, now the conventional wisdom was that women who wanted to continue working outside the home were neurotic.

collage magazine covers contrating WWII Women work covers and illustration of mother and child

Women’s magazines soon replaced the WWII working girl with a loving Mother who became the reigning cover girl for years, solidifying the only real worthwhile commitment for a woman was the fulfillment of themselves as wives and mothers. L) McCalls Cover 1942, (R) Ladies Home Journal cover 1946 illustration Al Parker

In her Junior year in college, a crippling cloud of pessimism had drifted over the fate of the modern American Woman and the American family.

According to a 1947 bestselling book both were in dire danger.

In sociology classes all across the country earnest student like my mother cast aside Margaret Mead and devoted college papers to a dense cerebral book co-authored by Marynia Farnham and Ferdinand Lundberg, a shrink and sociologist, called “Modern Woman: The Lost Sex.”

Vintage sexist illustration 1950s hero husband

If there were unhappiness and uncertainty in modern life they wrote, it had a sexual reason: the modern woman had denied her femininity and her womanly role.

Only by accepting her place as a wife, mother homemaker, and by erasing her “masculine aggressive” outside interests would a woman be content. Women who avoided this natural state were “neurotically disturbed women”.

Feminism was, “at it’s core, a deep illness.”

Mission Accomplished

collage cover Saturday Evening Post WWII Rosie Riveter contrasted with 1950s Housewife Cover Girl

Operation: June Cleaver – Mission Accomplished. (L) Vintage 1944 Saturday Evening Post Cover of Rosie the Riveter illustration by Robert Riggs (R) Vintage 1955 Saturday Evening Cover – illustration by Steve Dohanos

Operation June Cleaver was a success! Mission Accomplished!

During the post-war years, the Culture of Containment was not just foreign policy but applied to women and their identities as much as it did to the Soviets. Women were to contain their aspirations

It would be a long fifteen years before another, young Jewish woman named Betty, would step forward and write about “the problem that has no name.” So for now my mother Betty would follow in the footsteps of yet another Betty, ol’ reliable Betty Crocker, and become the perfect homemaker.

 

Betty-Crocker-Betty- Friedan

A tale of 2 Betty’s (L) Betty Crocker Vintage Ad 1950s (R) Betty Friedan

 

Copyright (©) 2020 Sally Edelstein All Rights Reserved

You Might Also Enjoy

The Mid Century Matrimony Ruth Bader Ginsburg Defied

9 comments

  1. Reblogged this on silverapplequeen and commented:
    Fabulous read. Great pictures.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Pierre Lagacé

    They should use your blog to teach history in schools Sally.

    Liked by 2 people

  3. Good post. One of the hardest books to read was written by Nicholas Kristof and his wife Sheryl WuDunn called “Half the Sky.” The title comes from a Chinese proverb that women hold up half the sky. The book focuses on the maltreatment of women around the world and even in the US. Former President Jimmy Carter wrote a sequel to this book about maltreatment of women in America called “A Call to Action.”

    Two points. (1) The maltreatment in both books speak of religious texts being used out of context to keep women as second class citizens and the horrific treatment like the sex slave industry, young girls being sold as wives, genital mutilation, fistula (which occurs when girls have babies before their bodies are ready), unpunished rapists in the military and on college campuses, and unequal pay.

    (2) Setting aside the above horrific subjects, “Half the Sky” points out that countries who treat women as second class citizens are competing in a world with only half its assets. Think about that. One of the key reasons America helped its allies win WWII is the manufacturing juggernaut on our shores building tanks, planes, weapons, armaments, etc. These manufacturing plants were staffed largely by women.

    I encourage folks to read both books, but I will tell you “Half the Sky” is well done, but a hard subject to take on. Be prepared. Keith

    Liked by 1 person

    • Thank you for that recommendation. Religious dogma interpreted to suit their needs has been the culprit of so much gender discrimination ( along with LGBTQ rights of course) That that mindset could be infiltrating our once seemingly neutral Supreme Court is deeply concerning.

      Liked by 2 people

      • Sally, so true. I added Jimmy Carter’s book as very few people know the Christian bible better than he does, as he has taught Sunday school for decades. He notes in “A Call to Action,” how much language to put women down is taken out of context.

        I have found it illuminating how the early Christian faith was kept alive by women who held services in their homes around the Mediterranean. A historian said after the Romans started putting down rebellious activities after Jesus was killed, Christians were scared – so it was these women who kept the fires burning, so to speak.

        But, most religious texts were largely written, edited, compiled and translated by “imperfect men.” Both words are important in the quotes. So, the efforts of women were not given the notoriety they deserved. Keith

        Liked by 1 person

  4. Fascinating analysis. This aspect of that period of history hadn’t occurred to me before.

    Do you think that the technological differences between 1945 and today would make this kind of campaign less effective? Back then ideas were distributed in more of a “broadcast from a center point” model, mostly flowing from the media to ordinary people with very little flow from person to person. Today, with the internet, there’s far more “lateral” networking-type communication which can undermine efforts to guide public feeling by top-down campaigns. I imagine that changes in advertising like the ones you describe would, today, be targets of a lot of ridicule and analysis on blogs and independent commentary sites.

    That wouldn’t protect against erosion of rights by a newly-wingnutized Supreme Court, but do you think it would make it harder for reactionaries to mold the mass public mind?

    Like

    • There is a much more sophisticated network of communications and immediacy as you point out that makes this vastly different than 1945. But propaganda has also gotten just as sophisticated adapting to this new technology of information and communication so that we are being manipulated as much as other generations who themselves thought they were more sophisticated than the preceding ones.

      Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: